Selection and Appraisal of Data- Summary

 

Selection and Appraisal of Data- Summary

Selection and appraisal of data are important processes in records management, digital curation, and research data management (UK Data Service,2019). The processes help organisations determine which data should be preserved, maintained, shared, or discarded. Institutions generate large volumes of digital and physical information daily hence it becomes impossible and expensive to retain all data permanently. Therefore, selection and appraisal ensure that only valuable, reliable, and relevant data are preserved for future use (Shepherd & Yeo, 2003).

Data selection refers to the process of identifying and choosing data that are considered important for long-term retention or preservation (International Council on Archives, 2016). The main aim of data selection is to retain information that has administrative, legal, historical, cultural, or research value. Selection decisions are often based on specific criteria such as the uniqueness of the data, relevance to organisational objectives, potential future use, quality, and significance. For example, universities may preserve research datasets, student records, and institutional reports because these records support accountability, future research, and institutional memory.

Data appraisal, on the other hand, is the process of evaluating data to determine their value and usefulness before decisions are made regarding retention or disposal. Appraisal helps institutions assess whether data are authentic, reliable, accessible, and worth preserving over time (International Council on Archives, 2016). During appraisal, records managers and data professionals examine factors such as legal requirements, ethical considerations, confidentiality, copyright issues, and research significance. Data with long-term value are selected for preservation, while obsolete, duplicated, or low-value data may be securely disposed of.

Selection and appraisal are essential in digital preservation because digital information is vulnerable to loss, corruption, and technological obsolescence. Without proper appraisal and selection, organisations may waste resources preserving unnecessary data while important information is neglected. Effective appraisal supports efficient storage management, reduces operational costs, and improves access to high-quality information (Creswell, 2014). In research environments, this promotes transparency and reproducibility by ensuring that datasets supporting published studies remain accessible for verification and reuse.

Several frameworks guide the selection and appraisal process. The Digital Curation Centre promotes lifecycle management of data, where appraisal and selection occur throughout the entire data lifecycle rather than at the final stage only. Similarly, the Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems developed the Open Archival Information System (OAIS) model, which provides standards for preserving and maintaining long-term access to digital information. These frameworks help organisations develop systematic approaches for preserving valuable data resources.

Selection and appraisal also support accountability and decision-making in organisations. Government institutions, universities, libraries, and businesses rely on well-managed data to support operations, policy development, and future planning. Properly appraised and selected data contribute to knowledge preservation, organisational memory, and compliance with legal and regulatory requirements (Pearce-Moses, 2005).

In conclusion, selection and appraisal of data are critical components of records management and digital curation. They help institutions identify valuable information, preserve important knowledge, reduce storage burdens, and ensure long-term accessibility of reliable data (UK Data Service, 2019).

 

 


References

Creswell, J. W. (2014). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (4th ed.). Sage Publications.

International Council on Archives. (2016). Principles and functional requirements for records in electronic office environments. International Council on Archives.

Pearce-Moses, R. (2005). A glossary of archival and records terminology. Society of American Archivists.

Shepherd, E., & Yeo, G. (2003). Managing records: A handbook of principles and practice. Facet Publishing.

UK Data Service. (2019). Managing and sharing data: Best practice for researchers. UK Data Service. https://ukdataservice.ac.u

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Organisational Issues: Summary

  Data Curation: Organisational issues (Summary) Data curation and preservation involve the management, maintenance and long-term protection of digital resources to ensure their continued accessibility, authenticity and usability. Cox et al. (2023) observed that while technological challenges are often highlighted, organisational issues are equally critical as they influence the effectiveness and sustainability of preservation programs. Cox et al. (2023) identified lack of clear policies and strategic frameworks for digital preservation as a major organisational challenge that affects data curation and preservation. Many institutions collect and manage digital information without comprehensive guidelines that define preservation objectives, responsibilities, retention schedules and access requirements. Without formal policies, preservation activities may be inconsistent and dependent on individual efforts rather than institutional commitment (Corrado and Sandy, 2017). Digital...
Read more

SUMMARY OF DATA COLLECTION AND REPOSITORIES

Data Collection and Repositories In the modern information-driven environment, organizations and research institutions rely heavily on data for decision-making, planning, and policy formulation. The processes of data collection and the use of data repositories are central to effective information management and governance. Data collection ensures that relevant and accurate information is gathered, while data repositories provide structured storage, preservation, and access to that information. They both form critical components of the data life-cycle and contribute to knowledge creation, transparency, and accountability in institutions such as universities and government organizations. Data collection refers to the systematic process of gathering, measuring, and recording information from various sources to answer research questions, support decision-making, or generate new knowledge (Creswell, 2014). It can be conducted using qualitative methods (such as interviews, observations,...
Read more

Using and Reusing data-Summary

Image
  Using and Reusing data-Summary Borgman (2015) defined using and reusing data as the process of applying collected information for decision-making, research, problem-solving, and innovation, while also allowing existing data to be used again for purposes different from the original intention. In modern organisations, academic institutions and governments, data is considered an important asset as it supports evidence-based planning hence improving efficiency. Data use involves analysing and interpreting information to meet specific objectives while data reuse involves accessing previously collected datasets for secondary analysis, validation of results, or new research studies (Johnson, 2017). The reuse of data has become increasingly important in research and information management because it helps save time, reduce research costs and avoid duplication of effort. Researchers can reuse data from earlier studies to compare findings, identify trends or answer new research questio...
Read more